Talk:Daryn Kagan: Difference between revisions

Content deleted Content added
Line 61:
 
:::::Does user:69.208.192.133 have anything esle to say in favor of this material? I think that we've shown that it is not in accord with our policies on sources. -[[User:Willmcw|Willmcw]] 06:17, 15 December 2005 (UTC)
::::::Willmcw, you have shown the material is not in accord with your personal narrow interpretation of our guidelines and our policies. You have not, however, shown discernment. Nevertheless, Kitty, do what you want with the statement that posters on the news industry tvspy.com forum (which is widely known in the television news industry and whose archives can only be accessed be paying a fee) criticized CNN anchor Daryn Kagan for interviewing the actor who plays Ned the banker in the ditech.com commercial. As mentioned before, there probably are citations in Wikipedia that are only in expensive journals. If you want to follow the dictum, "If we can't see it, then it isn't verifiable", when you excise the Ned the Banker information (which you will do), Kitty, think about beginning a project to excise any information that a person must pay a fee in order to see. If you want information cited from "notable" souces, start a similar project whose first task is to define "notable". Finally, if you excise the information because it is from a "forum", realize that Wikipedia may also be considered a "forum". Good luck. - The other editors can have the final comments on this matter (as if they won't make them anyway).
 
==Protected==